Hedging with VIX Derivatives

Last Updated: November 13, 2024

Notes

Hedging with VIX Derivatives explores strategies that utilize volatility as a tool for risk management in market downturns and turbulent conditions. This topic covers the nature of VIX derivatives, including futures and options on the VIX index, and how they function as instruments to hedge against sudden volatility spikes. It delves into the mechanics of VIX pricing, the factors that affect volatility, and the application of VIX products in a diversified portfolio. Understanding these strategies is essential for managing risk exposure effectively and optimizing portfolio resilience amid market fluctuations.

Free CMT Practice Test

Learning Objectives

In studying “Hedging with VIX Derivatives” for the CMT, you should learn to understand the role of the VIX (Volatility Index) as a measure of market volatility and its importance as a sentiment indicator. Identify the structure and types of VIX derivatives, such as VIX futures and options, and how they can be used to hedge against volatility risk. Analyze the factors affecting VIX derivative pricing, including the term structure of volatility and mean reversion. Evaluate strategies for incorporating VIX derivatives into a portfolio to mitigate downside risk during market turbulence. Additionally, develop an understanding of the limitations and costs of using VIX derivatives as a hedge and the potential impact on overall portfolio performance.

Understanding the VIX as a Market Volatility Measure

The VIX, or Volatility Index, is one of the most widely used measures of market volatility, capturing investor expectations for future price swings in the S&P 500 index. Managed by the Chicago Board Options Exchange (CBOE), the VIX provides insight into how much volatility market participants anticipate over the next 30 days. Here’s a closer look at how the VIX functions as a market volatility measure, its calculations, and its applications.

1. What is the VIX?

The VIX represents the market’s expectation of 30-day forward-looking volatility, based on the prices of options on the S&P 500 index.
Often called the “fear gauge,” the VIX rises when investors expect large market swings, reflecting greater uncertainty and potential risk in the market.
Conversely, a low VIX suggests stability and low anticipated volatility, often associated with periods of market confidence.

2. How the VIX is Calculated

The VIX is derived from the prices of near-term S&P 500 index options, including both calls and puts, which indicate the range of expected price movements.
Specifically, the VIX calculation uses a weighted average of options with expirations around 30 days from the calculation date. The prices of these options reflect the premium investors are willing to pay for protection or speculation based on anticipated volatility.
The calculation does not measure actual or historical volatility; rather, it focuses on implied volatility — the market’s consensus forecast of how volatile the S&P 500 will be over the next month.

3. Interpreting VIX Levels as a Measure of Market Volatility

High VIX (Above 30): A high VIX level indicates that investors expect substantial price swings. High VIX values are often associated with market uncertainty, fear, or significant news events, such as economic crises, political events, or global instability.
Moderate VIX (15-30): This range indicates moderate volatility expectations, suggesting some uncertainty in the market but not extreme fear. It is often seen during times of economic change, earnings season, or heightened news activity.
Low VIX (Below 15): A low VIX level reflects low expected volatility, generally indicating investor confidence and stable market conditions. This typically aligns with periods of market optimism or complacency.

Structure and Types of VIX Derivatives

VIX derivatives are financial instruments that allow investors to trade on the expected volatility of the market as indicated by the VIX index. These derivatives, such as futures, options, ETFs, and ETNs, are not based on the VIX index directly but rather on expectations of future VIX levels. Here’s a detailed look at the structure and types of VIX derivatives:

1. VIX Futures

Structure: VIX futures contracts allow investors to buy or sell the expected value of the VIX at a future date. These contracts are standardized and trade on the CBOE Futures Exchange.
How They Work: VIX futures do not track the spot price of the VIX index directly. Instead, they are based on the market’s expectation of where the VIX will be on the contract’s expiration date.
Maturity: VIX futures are available with different expiration dates, allowing investors to choose short-term or longer-term contracts.
Uses: VIX futures are commonly used for hedging against market volatility, speculating on changes in volatility, and as a component in more complex trading strategies.
Considerations: Since VIX futures reflect expectations of future volatility rather than current market volatility, they often exhibit “contango” (where future prices are higher than the spot price) or “backwardation” (where future prices are lower than the spot price), impacting returns for long-term holders.

2. VIX Options

Structure: VIX options give the holder the right, but not the obligation, to buy or sell VIX futures at a specified price before the option expires. These are options on VIX futures rather than the VIX index itself.
Types: There are two types of VIX options: calls (the right to buy) and puts (the right to sell). Call options are often used to bet on rising volatility, while put options are used to bet on falling volatility.
Expiration and Settlement: VIX options are European-style, meaning they can only be exercised at expiration, and they are cash-settled based on the VIX futures settlement price.
Uses: VIX options are used for hedging, volatility trading, and speculative purposes. They allow traders to gain exposure to volatility with limited capital compared to futures.
Considerations: Like VIX futures, VIX options are sensitive to the term structure of VIX futures, which can affect the pricing and profitability of option positions.

3. VIX Exchange-Traded Products (ETPs)

VIX ETPs, such as ETFs (Exchange-Traded Funds) and ETNs (Exchange-Traded Notes), are designed to provide exposure to the VIX index or a specific segment of the VIX futures curve. They allow retail and institutional investors to access VIX-related strategies without directly trading futures or options.

VIX ETFs:
- Structure: VIX ETFs are funds that hold a portfolio of VIX futures contracts, typically a mix of short-term or mid-term futures.
- Types:
  - Short-Term VIX ETFs: These track the daily performance of the first- and second-month VIX futures contracts, closely reflecting short-term changes in volatility.
  - Mid-Term VIX ETFs: These track a blend of longer-dated VIX futures (typically four to seven months out) and offer less sensitivity to daily VIX changes.
- Use Cases: VIX ETFs are popular for hedging, short-term trading, and speculation on rising volatility.
- Considerations: VIX ETFs are subject to the costs of rolling futures contracts, especially during contango, which can lead to “roll yield” losses over time. They are generally not suitable for long-term holding due to these structural costs.
VIX ETNs:
- Structure: VIX ETNs are debt instruments issued by financial institutions, tracking VIX futures indices rather than holding actual assets. The issuer agrees to pay the holder the returns based on the performance of a specific VIX futures strategy.
- Types: Like ETFs, there are both short-term and mid-term VIX ETNs, each tracking different segments of the VIX futures curve.
- Use Cases: VIX ETNs are similar to VIX ETFs in that they are used for hedging and volatility speculation.
- Considerations: ETNs carry additional credit risk, as they are backed by the issuer’s credit rather than actual assets. Investors should consider the issuer’s creditworthiness, as the ETN is only as secure as the issuer’s ability to pay.

4. Inverse VIX Derivatives

Structure: Inverse VIX products allow investors to profit from declining volatility. These products are typically structured as inverse ETFs or ETNs that deliver the opposite daily performance of a VIX futures index.
How They Work: When the VIX falls, inverse VIX products increase in value, making them suitable for investors who believe volatility will decrease or remain low.
Use Cases: Inverse VIX products are used by investors who anticipate reduced volatility and want to benefit from declining market fear or panic.
Considerations: Inverse VIX products are highly volatile and not suitable for long-term holding, as they suffer from compounding effects and can lead to significant losses if volatility rises sharply.

5. Leveraged VIX Derivatives

Structure: Leveraged VIX derivatives amplify daily returns of a VIX futures index by 2x or 3x. These are often structured as leveraged ETFs or ETNs and provide two or three times the daily performance of the VIX futures they track.
Use Cases: Leveraged VIX derivatives are suitable for aggressive, short-term trading strategies, allowing traders to maximize returns from short-term volatility spikes.
Considerations: Leveraged VIX products are subject to decay due to daily resetting, and their returns can deviate significantly from the expected multiplier over time, especially in volatile markets. They are best suited for very short-term holding periods.

Strategies for Incorporating VIX Derivatives in a Portfolio

Incorporating VIX derivatives into a portfolio can provide valuable hedging, diversification, and speculative opportunities, especially during periods of heightened volatility. VIX derivatives like futures, options, ETFs, and ETNs allow investors to manage risk and potentially profit from changes in market volatility. Here are some strategies for using VIX derivatives within a portfolio:

1. Hedging Against Market Declines

Strategy: During times of market uncertainty, VIX derivatives can act as a hedge, offsetting potential losses in equity holdings. VIX products typically rise in value when the stock market falls, as fear and volatility increase.
Instruments: VIX call options or VIX ETFs (especially short-term VIX ETFs) are often used for hedging. Purchasing call options provides exposure to volatility spikes without tying up significant capital.
Implementation: Adding a small allocation to VIX derivatives can serve as a form of insurance, providing upside during market declines and helping to stabilize the overall portfolio.
Considerations: VIX derivatives are often short-term tools, so regular re-evaluation and adjustment are required, especially if the portfolio hedging needs change as volatility subsides.

2. Diversifying with VIX as a Non-Correlated Asset

Strategy: Since the VIX tends to move inversely to the stock market, incorporating VIX derivatives can help reduce overall portfolio volatility by adding a non-correlated asset.
Instruments: VIX ETFs or a mix of short- and mid-term VIX futures provide diversified exposure to volatility.
Implementation: A small allocation to VIX derivatives, even during stable periods, can improve risk-adjusted returns by reducing the portfolio’s overall volatility profile.
Considerations: Due to decay and roll yield costs, VIX products are not ideal for long-term holding. Rotating into or out of VIX derivatives as volatility expectations change is often necessary to avoid performance erosion.

3. Short-Term Speculation on Volatility Spikes

Strategy: Some investors use VIX derivatives to speculate on short-term increases in volatility, such as around earnings season, Federal Reserve announcements, or geopolitical events.
Instruments: Short-term VIX futures, VIX call options, or leveraged VIX ETFs can be effective for short-term speculation on rising volatility.
Implementation: Traders may take a position in these derivatives just before expected volatility events and close out the position after the event. Leveraged VIX ETFs can amplify returns for short-term trades but are typically held only for a few days.
Considerations: This approach requires precise timing and a clear exit strategy, as leveraged VIX products and VIX futures are sensitive to the daily fluctuations of volatility and can lead to significant losses if the volatility spike does not materialize.

4. Protecting Gains in a Bull Market

Strategy: VIX derivatives can protect a portfolio from sudden downturns while maintaining exposure to the equity market. This is useful in bull markets, where investors want to stay invested in equities but need downside protection.
Instruments: VIX call options or a small allocation in VIX ETFs can serve as a buffer if volatility suddenly rises.
Implementation: Allocate a percentage of gains into VIX derivatives to create a “volatility cushion.” If the market corrects, the rise in VIX can help offset some of the equity losses, allowing the portfolio to retain more of its gains.
Considerations: Since the VIX can remain low for extended periods during strong bull markets, re-evaluating the allocation to VIX derivatives is necessary to avoid incurring costs without benefits.

5. Income Generation Through VIX Option Selling

Strategy: Selling VIX options, especially put options, is a way to generate income from stable or falling volatility environments. When volatility is high, VIX option premiums increase, creating an opportunity for income generation.
Instruments: Selling VIX put options allows investors to earn premium income, betting that volatility will not rise significantly.
Implementation: In times of elevated VIX, investors can sell put options and collect premiums, benefiting from time decay and the potential for volatility to decrease.
Considerations: This strategy is best suited for investors with a high-risk tolerance, as selling options can lead to significant losses if volatility spikes unexpectedly. Additionally, option sellers need to have sufficient collateral and must monitor positions closely.

6. Contrarian Investing with Mean Reversion

Strategy: The VIX often exhibits mean-reverting behavior, making it a valuable tool for contrarian investors who seek to buy low and sell high. This involves buying VIX derivatives when volatility is low (anticipating a rise) and selling or reducing positions when volatility is high (anticipating a fall).
Instruments: VIX futures and VIX ETFs are commonly used for mean-reversion strategies.
Implementation: When the VIX is near historic lows, increase exposure to VIX derivatives in anticipation of higher volatility. Conversely, when the VIX is elevated, reduce or sell the VIX positions to capitalize on mean reversion.
Considerations: Mean reversion strategies require patience and timing, as low VIX levels can persist for extended periods, and high VIX levels may not immediately revert to the mean.

7. Portfolio Insurance with Inverse VIX Derivatives

Strategy: Inverse VIX ETFs and ETNs allow investors to profit from falling volatility, providing portfolio insurance when markets are expected to calm down after periods of high volatility.
Instruments: Inverse VIX ETFs, such as those providing -1x exposure to VIX futures, are typically used.
Implementation: Add inverse VIX products during times of heightened volatility with the expectation that the market will return to stability. Inverse VIX products can offset losses in volatility-linked hedges or even act as short-term bets on declining volatility.
Considerations: Inverse VIX products are sensitive to market timing and can incur losses quickly if volatility rises instead of falls. They are also subject to daily compounding effects, making them more suited for short-term use.

8. Leveraged VIX Derivatives for Tactical Allocation

Strategy: Leveraged VIX products can be used as tactical short-term positions, allowing investors to amplify exposure to expected volatility changes.
Instruments: 2x or 3x leveraged VIX ETFs and ETNs provide amplified returns based on daily movements in the VIX.
Implementation: Enter leveraged VIX positions before anticipated volatility events for higher potential returns, with the expectation of closing out positions quickly.
Considerations: Leveraged VIX products are not suitable for holding periods beyond a few days due to the effects of daily rebalancing and decay. These products can lead to substantial losses if volatility does not increase as expected, so they require precise entry and exit timing.

Limitations and Costs of Using VIX Derivatives as a Hedge

Using VIX derivatives as a hedge can be an effective way to protect a portfolio against market volatility, but it also comes with several limitations and costs that investors need to be aware of. Here are the key limitations and costs associated with using VIX derivatives, such as futures, options, ETFs, and ETNs, as a hedge:

1. Short-Term Nature of VIX Derivatives

Limitation: VIX derivatives are typically designed for short-term volatility exposure. They reflect expected volatility over the next 30 days, which limits their effectiveness for long-term hedging strategies.
Cost: Because VIX products are most effective in the short term, longer holding periods can lead to losses from price decay or adverse movements, especially in periods of low or declining volatility.

2. Decay and Roll Yield Costs in Futures-Based Products

Limitation: VIX ETFs and ETNs are often based on VIX futures, which require regular rolling of contracts from one month to the next. When the VIX futures curve is in contango (where near-term contracts are cheaper than longer-dated ones), the cost of rolling futures results in negative roll yield, gradually eroding the value of the product.
Cost: Roll yield costs can be substantial in a prolonged contango environment, leading to “roll decay,” where the price of the VIX ETF or ETN declines over time, even if the VIX index remains stable.

3. Complexity of VIX Term Structure

Limitation: The VIX futures market often exhibits contango or backwardation, making it challenging to predict how VIX derivatives will perform over time. This complexity means that VIX derivatives do not always move in line with the VIX index itself, as they are based on future volatility expectations rather than the current VIX.
Cost: Investors may incur unexpected losses or reduced hedge effectiveness if they do not fully understand the impact of the term structure on VIX derivatives, particularly in periods when the futures curve changes direction.

4. High Volatility of VIX Products

Limitation: VIX derivatives, by nature, are highly volatile and tend to experience larger price swings than traditional equity investments. This volatility can make them difficult to hold, as the value of these products can change rapidly, potentially undermining their intended hedge if not managed carefully.
Cost: High volatility can lead to substantial losses if the hedge does not perform as expected. Investors may need to dedicate significant capital to maintain the hedge, especially in leveraged or short-term products that amplify these price swings.

5. Compounding Effects in Leveraged and Inverse Products

Limitation: Leveraged VIX products (e.g., 2x or 3x ETFs) and inverse VIX products reset daily, meaning their returns compound based on daily movements. This compounding effect can lead to significant tracking error over time, especially in volatile markets, causing the product’s performance to deviate from the expected multiple.
Cost: Leveraged and inverse products incur costs due to daily rebalancing, and these costs compound over time, leading to “decay” that can erode returns. They are generally unsuitable for long-term hedging, as the compounding effect makes it challenging to achieve a stable hedge position over time.

6. Opportunity Cost of Capital

Limitation: Allocating capital to VIX derivatives as a hedge can tie up funds that could otherwise be invested in potentially income-generating or appreciating assets. This is especially relevant in low-volatility periods when the VIX and its derivatives may provide little to no return.
Cost: The opportunity cost of hedging with VIX derivatives can be significant, as the capital used for the hedge does not grow as it might in other investments, potentially leading to a drag on portfolio performance if the anticipated volatility event does not materialize.

7. Tracking Error in VIX ETFs and ETNs

Limitation: VIX ETFs and ETNs, which attempt to replicate the VIX or its futures, often have tracking error due to the difficulty in perfectly matching the performance of the VIX index. This discrepancy arises because these products use VIX futures, which don’t directly track the VIX spot price.
Cost: Tracking error can result in an ineffective hedge, as the ETF or ETN may not increase in value to the same extent as the VIX index during a market downturn, reducing the hedge’s effectiveness. This misalignment between the derivative product and the actual index can lead to unexpected losses.

8. Credit Risk in VIX ETNs

Limitation: Unlike ETFs, ETNs are debt instruments issued by financial institutions. This structure introduces credit risk, as the performance of an ETN is contingent on the issuer’s ability to meet its obligations.
Cost: If the issuer of a VIX ETN faces financial difficulty, investors may suffer losses independent of the ETN’s market performance. During times of market stress, credit risk in ETNs can further impact their value, making them less reliable as a hedge.

Examples

Example 1: Protecting Against Market Volatility

Investors use VIX derivatives, such as VIX futures or options, to hedge against anticipated market volatility. For example, if an investor holds a diversified portfolio but expects a period of high market uncertainty, they may purchase VIX call options. If the market becomes more volatile, the VIX rises, and the options increase in value, offsetting portfolio losses.

Example 2: Corporate Risk Management

A corporation with significant exposure to market fluctuations—such as one in the finance or technology sector—can hedge against the potential negative impacts of volatility by using VIX futures. If the company anticipates increased volatility during earnings season or other major events, hedging with VIX derivatives can mitigate potential declines in stock prices that are driven by market-wide fear and uncertainty.

Example 3: Institutional Portfolio Hedging

Large institutional investors, such as pension funds or mutual funds, use VIX derivatives as part of their risk management strategy. By incorporating VIX options or futures into their portfolios, these investors can protect themselves from sharp market drops. For instance, if the investor anticipates an upcoming economic shock, VIX derivatives allow them to offset the risk of heavy losses in their stock holdings due to a surge in volatility.

Example 4: Tactical Hedging for Traders

Traders who use short-term strategies often utilize VIX derivatives to protect themselves from unexpected spikes in volatility, especially during periods of market uncertainty. A trader may use short-term VIX futures to hedge against a potential market correction or heightened uncertainty in the days or weeks ahead. If the market becomes more volatile, the VIX derivatives would increase in value, offsetting any losses from the trader’s long positions.

Example 5: Hedging in Options Markets

In options trading, where implied volatility plays a critical role in pricing options, VIX derivatives can be used to hedge volatility risk. For example, an options trader who has a large exposure to volatility may buy VIX call options as a hedge. If the market becomes more volatile and the VIX rises, the value of the VIX calls increases, offsetting the volatility risk in the options portfolio. This allows the trader to manage the impact of market swings on their positions.

Practice Questions

Question 1

What is the primary purpose of using VIX derivatives for hedging?

A) To increase portfolio returns
B) To protect against volatility risk in the market
C) To gain exposure to a specific stock
D) To avoid all forms of risk in the market

Correct Answer: B) To protect against volatility risk in the market.

Explanation: VIX derivatives, such as VIX futures and options, are primarily used to hedge against market volatility. When investors expect significant market swings, they use these derivatives to offset potential losses due to increased volatility. Options A and C are incorrect because VIX derivatives are not designed to directly increase returns or gain exposure to specific stocks. Option D is also incorrect, as hedging with VIX derivatives cannot eliminate all types of risk—only those related to market volatility.

Question 2

An institutional investor anticipates a sharp market downturn. Which of the following strategies would be most suitable for hedging with VIX derivatives?

A) Buying VIX call options
B) Selling VIX futures
C) Buying VIX put options
D) Shorting individual stocks

Correct Answer: A) Buying VIX call options.

Explanation: Buying VIX call options is an effective strategy for hedging against expected market downturns. If the market becomes more volatile and the VIX index rises, the value of VIX call options also increases, helping offset losses from other portfolio assets. Selling VIX futures or buying VIX put options would not hedge against rising volatility, and shorting individual stocks exposes the investor to specific stock risks rather than hedging broader market volatility.

Question 3

Which of the following investors would most likely benefit from using VIX derivatives?

A) A short-term trader looking to hedge against sudden market corrections
B) A long-term investor focused on dividend income
C) A real estate investor without equity exposure
D) A bondholder seeking protection from interest rate fluctuations

Correct Answer: A) A short-term trader looking to hedge against sudden market corrections.

Explanation: VIX derivatives are particularly useful for investors who anticipate short-term volatility in the market, such as sudden corrections or price swings. A short-term trader would benefit from using VIX derivatives to hedge against these risks. In contrast, a long-term investor focused on dividends, a real estate investor, and a bondholder are less exposed to direct market volatility, making VIX derivatives less relevant to their strategies.